Warning - research-related rant ahead.
Just looking over the DDN's "local news" feed. Let's see...
Layoffs.Accidents.Gypsy moth spraying.Runaway mom (still? C'mon, isn't there a reality show on?)
People walk in the rain for a benefit.Blacks have to wait longer for organs... but [SARCASM ALERT] of course, it's all
their fault because they don't donate enough (
maybe because of their faith).
That last bit needs a little explanation (and here's where the researcher in me gets ranty). Like,
why does your race matter with organ donation? Sure, you can find studies that suggest that race may have an impact on recipient survival.
Here's one, in fact. But there's three important things to note from this article:
1. They're reporting on
non-black recipients getting organs from
black donors, not the other way around.
2. They mention that it seems to really be Hepatitis C infection, not "race" that made the difference.
3. They also
explicitly say that:
"It is important to remember that the statistical difference in this observation is greatly outweighed by the life-giving benefits that recipients get from transplantation."
So you gotta ask - why is there a race disparity in the organ donor waiting list?
Or maybe the reporter didn't actually do their homework.
The transplant waiting list at MVH is 45% black... and the population of Dayton proper
was 43% black (as of the 2000 census). I guess "Blacks must wait longer to get organ transplants" (along with the message that it's somehow Black people's fault) sounds a little more interesting than "Local hospital's waiting list reflects the demographics of the community immediately around it."
And yes, I'm aware that I'm citing statistics for Dayton proper and not the entire "Greater Dayton Area". But then we'd also have to evaluate how many people from Oakwood, Kettering, Beavercreek and so on travel to Columbus or Cincinnati for transplants as well, or use hospital networks other than MVH. It
would be interesting to see what that additional information is like, and see if it reflects the
national disparity. But I don't have that information - and apparently, neither did the DDN.
Then again, I'm not a news organization trying to sell newspapers.

All the news that's... well...